Unplugged
Posted in Tech on February 19th, 2012 No Comments »

We finally did what millions of others are doing: we pulled the plug on paid TV. Specifically, we got rid of our DirecTV satellite service. I'll admit it, I was a little anxious at first. We don't watch a whole lot of TV (and espeically not since Leo was born) but we do enjoy plopping down and watching something when we do get the chance.
We have a Home Theater PC as a DVR and it recorded everything we found interesting off of the satellite- so there was always a long pile up of recorded shows waiting for us. My faves are Discovery Channel, History, Military, Investigation Discovery, The Learning Channel, etc.
But cable and satellite service is (IMHO) way too expensive. In this day and age, there are alternatives. In droves, many people are ditching the paid services and turning to the great equalizer- (no, not firearms) …the Internet.
Rather than a cable or dish, 300+ channels (out of which you end up watching only 6 or 7) and an inflated monthly bill, the new choice is a high speed internet connection, a PC or streaming media device hooked up to the TV, and whatever programming is online.
So far, I'm not missing the satellite. (Granted, we still have the softened-blow of several hundred programs recorded to the PC).
Below is my list of must-haves for jumping to Internet-only TV:
#1: Netflix streaming.

One can argue their online service doesn't have the latest/greatest selection of content, and one would be right. However, thus far, it's the best game in town. The simple fact is, the powers that be (major studios, TV networks) don't want Internet-only delivery to be any better than it currently is, because it's the kiss of death to their dominance. They want you to pay $80+ a month for the shows they produce/broadcast. (That AND sit through their advertising- cake and eat it.) They want you buying discs, not streaming them- hence their fighting tooth and nail to prevent netflix from getting too much of the best content online before they've had a chance to gouge every nickel possible via traditional distribution.
But netflix is huge, popular, profitable and it's not going away any time soon, so even though the content providers would love to squash it like a bug- they can't. But it IS the only game in town, and it will remain that way. If you're looking for a better source of online streaming with newer/better stuff that's just as cheap: keep dreaming. For the foreseeable future this is as good as it gets.
And for Leila and me, it's pretty good. No, I can't watch the latest Hollywood blockbusters two days after they're released on DVD via online streaming, but they do have a modestly decent back catalog of movies and TV series- including a lot of the Discovery series that I like.
And Netflix streaming is easy to access. Every other new TV, streaming media box, DVD or BluRay player sold these days has access to it built in. And of course any HTPC. Done deal.
#2. Home Theater PC

This relates directly to #1 on my list. If you're completely satisfied with Netflix as the pinnacle of Internet provided entertainment (which it pretty much is) then you'll be happy without #2. You can use any of the 1,000's of dirt-cheap devices (streaming media boxes, DVD/BluRay players, TV's etc) that are 'Internet connected'.
But here's the rub: most of these devices are only internet connected in that they connect to the internet to get Netflix and maybe one or two other (usually less-than-stellar) sources. So you're not actually getting "the Internet" on your TV. It's an important distinction to note. If you were thinking you'd be watching from a choice of unlimited YouTube, Vimeo, Hulu, Network TV online content, endless streaming music, as well as Googling anything that just crosses your mind using a traditional web-browser, well… you won't be.
And although Netflix IS the pinnacle of Internet-entertainment, keep in mind that all the other possible sources combined offer a lot of choices. It's easy to think: "Well hell, how much crap do you need? Isn't one source enough? I don't watch all that much!" But in reality- that's just it. I don't watch that much TV. Which translates to: I only watch what I like, not just any old thing that's on. Which then translates to: the stuff I like to watch is harder to find. No one provider is going to have the shows I like all in one neat stack just for me. I'm going to need a lot of options in order to find *anything* that interests me.
This is where an HTPC fits the bill perfectly.
An HTPC is just a PC (or Mac) that hooks up to an HDTV. With a few tweaks to make using it suitable from across the room, it's the do-it-all solution. You've of course got Netflix. You have access to anything on the web. Mountains of stuff on YouTube. Classic TV series on archive.org and other sources. Radio stations. Endless music from any artist that's ever recorded. And the list goes on. "Internet-connected" with a PC means just that, in exactly the sense you're used to.
It doesn't have to be a fancy-schmancy setup like the above image; it can be a crappy old beige box PC, a laptop, a nettop, or virtually any internet-connected PC with DVI orHDMI output that you can hook up to your HDTV and sound system. Even a modest PC with decent video and audio hardware can effectively replace every other set top device, and deliver any and everything found online to your TV.
You should also have a decent HTPC keyboard with a point device built in, and/or a decent HTPC remote. (IE: like a Windows Media Center remote).
#3. Software and Internet Sites
There's Netflix of course, but there's also Hulu (I personally don't find the paid Hulu Plus worth subscribing to. Browse their content selection, and if you can find more than 3 or 4 shows you've even heard of before, let alone want to pay to watch- then go for it. Otherwise, they're clearly in the tank for the powers-that-be. Which makes sense, since they are a creation of the powers-that-be.) Boxee, Amazon Video, Xfinity, and Sidereel. Most of these sites are aggregators for the content that's also available on the online streaming sites of most of the major broadcast and cable networks.

Our living room HTPC setup, using the Kylo web-browser which is built to aggregate much of the content online into an easy to use 10ft interface
#4. An HDTV Antenna
Don't discount good ol' fashioned OTA broadcast TV. These days all the major broadcasters broadcast in full HD, and most modern HDTVs have a tuner built in. If you have an HTPC, you can get a cheap ATSC tuner to schedule and record broadcasts in DVR fashion. For best results, stick an antenna on your roof and (if directional) use antennaweb.org (along with Google Maps) to determine the exact best spot to aim it. Otherwise you can use an indoor ATSC antenna, but your results may vary.
The Pros of going online-only:
1. Price. Much online content is free. Netflix's streaming service is $7.99 a month.
2. Picture Quality. Provided you have a fairly speedy cable or DSL connection, content is in most cases HD-quality. For us, it's been mostly a step-up vs. the mostly standard-def content we watched via satellite.
3. No storage requirements. Content is online, not stored on your computer or device.
4. Advertisements. If you're used to sitting through commercials anyway because you don't use a DVR to record programs and skip commercials, then this will be a plus for you. Online advertising (thus far) tends to be very short commercials at 10-15 seconds each, then back to the show.
The Cons of going online-only:
1. Finding what you actually want to watch, when you want to watch it. That can be difficult. Most content providers are pushing their more traditional distribution methods first, and online content begrudgingly dead-last. So few are working terribly hard to make things as easy as they could be. Most first run episodes of popular series aren't posted online until at least a day or two after they've aired. The back catalog of a series isn't likely to stay online for long either, as that's prime syndication/DVD collection material for the providers. So you'll mostly be watching things later than their original air date. If you don't care about discussing some show the next day after it aired, then you won't care if you're waiting a few days to see it.
2. Advertisements. Even though significantly shorter than on-air commercials, if you're used to a DVR and skipping commercials altogether (raising my hand) you'll find it jarring to suddenly have to suffer through them. But the concept is clearly justified. When I'm paying a hefty monthly fee for service, I think it's fair to skip the commercials which paid cable was originally supposed to eliminate. (Ever notice how the concept quickly fell by the wayside? Heck, even premium cable and public TV is chock-full of commercials as the broadcasters have their cake and eat it too.) With online content, its the only source revenue, so having to suffer through ads is reasonable. You can skip through most online shows, in DVR-fashion, but each time you do, you'll likely be forced to watch at least 15 seconds or so of commercials that can't be skipped.
3. A decent experience totally depends on your Internet speed. Dial up? Forget about it. Entry-level DSL? You'll probably have a fairly good experience, with perhaps the occasional pause due to buffering. Highest-speed DSL or cable? Generally you won't have problems. Keep in mind if you're uploading/downloading a lot of stuff at the same time you're trying to stream live content, you may run into glitches.
4. The future is unknown. The powers-that-be are deathly afraid of the Internet. Networks that love having a monopoly on content. Studios that want higher profits from their traditional content distribution. Politicians that can't stand the idea of information counter to their state-approved spin being freely distributed. (Basically ALL politicians, and yes, in the first world every bit as much as the third).
Together, all of these forces are very happy to collaborate and present the Internet as a threat: to democracy, to profits, to 'the children' to job creation, to virtually every hot-button issue one can name. The 'solution' -as it always is among such unholy allies- is regulation and restriction in the guise of anti-piracy (read: censorship).
There's also the pretense that the resource itself is in limited supply (the whole myth of 'bandwidth' being a limited commodity). These Zillion-dollar corporations are hurt desperately by you downloading unlimited amounts of data, so they must impose limits "for your own good".
And the biggest ploy of all: the Internet itself in current form is "dangerous", a wicked den of porn, piracy and propaganda that no one can possibly navigate without a state-approved/corporate-sponsored nanny. Witness the recent SOPA and PIPA bills in the US congress for examples. So the Internet and bandwidth freedom we know today could one day become as restricted as the airwaves are currently- where individuals are forbidden to broadcast their own unlicensed content "for their own good." So enjoy streaming endless gobs of data while it lasts, just know that it may not last in its current unmolested state forever.


1.
2.
Apple's website today. 






















